Flooring

Laminate vs. Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring: Which Is Right for Your Home?

By Wall to Wall Construction · Catonsville, MD · 7 min read
Wood floor running through a living space in a home remodeled by Wall to Wall Construction
Short answer

Choose luxury vinyl plank (LVP) for kitchens, bathrooms, laundry rooms and basements, because new vinyl products are waterproof. Choose laminate for dry living rooms, bedrooms and upper floors, where its thicker, firmer plank feels more like wood underfoot. Installed prices overlap: HomeGuide lists laminate at $4 to $14 per square foot and luxury vinyl at $4 to $16. Many homes end up with both.

When homeowners in Baltimore, Towson and Owings Mills ask us about new floors, the question often comes down to two products that look alike in the showroom: laminate and luxury vinyl plank. Both give you a wood look for less than hardwood, both click together as floating floors, and both come in hundreds of colors. They behave very differently once water, a concrete slab or a busy kitchen gets involved.

This guide compares the two using published cost and lifespan data from HomeGuide and Angi, plus what we see on installations in Maryland homes.

What each floor is made of

Laminate has a core of high-density fiberboard, a wood-based panel, with a printed photo layer and a clear wear layer on top. Because the core is wood fiber, standard laminate can swell if water gets into the seams. Laminate is graded by an abrasion (AC) rating; a higher rating means it holds up to more foot traffic.

Luxury vinyl plank is built from layers of vinyl, often over a rigid stone-plastic or wood-plastic core, with a printed layer and a wear layer on top. The wear layer is the main thing that separates a budget plank from a premium one, and Angi notes that vinyl plank pricing rises with wear layer thickness.

Side-by-side comparison

LaminateLuxury vinyl plank
Installed cost (HomeGuide)$4 to $14 per sq. ft.$4 to $16 per sq. ft.
Material only (HomeGuide)$1 to $6 per sq. ft.$2 to $10 per sq. ft.
WaterWater resistant; only some products are waterproofNew vinyl products are waterproof
Thickness (Angi)6 to 12 mm, with a cushioned feelAbout 5 mm on average
Lifespan (HomeGuide)10 to 25 years20 to 50 years
Best roomsLiving rooms, bedrooms, upper floorsKitchens, baths, laundry, basements
Lifespan estimates vary by source. Angi puts laminate at 10 to 30 years and vinyl at 10 to 25 years and calls the two about equal in durability. The quality of the product and the installation matter more than the category.

Water and moisture

This is the biggest difference between the two. HomeGuide says all laminate is water resistant but not all of it is waterproof, while all new vinyl flooring is waterproof. Angi warns that moisture in laminate seams can cause swelling and warping that cannot be repaired, and it does not recommend laminate for kitchens or basements.

Waterproof planks do not make a room waterproof. HomeGuide points out that water can still get through the seams of plank and tile vinyl to the subfloor. In a bathroom or laundry room, that means sealing the edges properly and dealing with leaks quickly, whichever floor you choose.

Some newer laminates are sold as waterproof. If you want laminate in a kitchen, check the manufacturer’s water rating and warranty terms for that exact product.

Cost

On price, the two overlap more than most people expect. HomeGuide lists laminate at $4 to $14 per square foot installed and luxury vinyl plank or tile at $4 to $16, with materials alone at $1 to $6 for laminate and $2 to $10 for vinyl. Angi’s materials figures are similar: about $1 per square foot for 7 mm laminate up to $5 for 12 mm planks, and $2.50 to $7 for luxury vinyl plank or tile depending on the wear layer.

The material is only part of the bill. In the homes we work in, these items often move the total as much as the product does:

  • Old flooring removal, especially glued-down vinyl or tile.
  • Subfloor leveling, since floating floors need a flat base and older floors have settled.
  • Stairs, which take treads, nosings and far more labor per square foot.
  • Trim and transitions at doorways, carpet edges and fireplace hearths.

These figures are national, and every house is different, so use them for planning and get an itemized estimate for your floors.

Kitchen and dining area with wood flooring installed by Wall to Wall Construction
One floor carried from the kitchen into the dining area. In a kitchen, a waterproof plank is the lower-risk choice.

Comfort, look and noise

Laminate is thicker, 6 to 12 mm according to Angi, so it feels firm and solid underfoot and closer to real wood. Vinyl plank averages about 5 mm and ranges from stiff to slightly soft depending on the core. Rigid-core vinyl feels more like laminate than older flexible vinyl did.

Both are floating floors, so the underlayment matters for sound. A good underlayment cuts the hollow sound when you walk across the room, and in condos and apartments the building often sets a minimum sound rating. Either floor can look convincing today; higher-end products of both types use deeper embossing that follows the printed grain.

Neither one adds resale value the way hardwood or natural stone can, Angi notes, though both are an upgrade over worn carpet or dated sheet vinyl.

Room-by-room picks

Choose LVPKitchens, full bathrooms, laundry and mudrooms, basements on a concrete slab, and homes with pets or young children.
Choose laminateLiving and dining rooms, bedrooms, home offices and upper floors where water is not a regular concern.
Either worksHallways and family rooms on the main level. Pick for feel and look, and match the floor in the next room.

Basements deserve a closer look. A below-grade slab can carry moisture even when it looks dry, so we test it before recommending any floor. Vinyl plank tolerates that environment far better than a fiberboard core. Our guide to basement finishing in Maryland covers moisture control, egress and permits for the rest of the project.

Finished basement game room with wet bar and pool table remodeled by Wall to Wall Construction
A finished lower level. Below-grade rooms need a floor that can handle moisture from the slab.

Installation in older Maryland homes

Many houses around Baltimore were built decades ago, and the floor you see is rarely the first one. A few things come up again and again when we install laminate or vinyl plank:

  • Original hardwood underneath. If there is solid wood under the carpet, refinishing it may make more sense than covering it.
  • Uneven subfloors. Settled framing and humps over beams have to be leveled, or the planks will flex and the joints can separate.
  • Door and trim heights. Adding a new floor over an old one can mean trimming doors and resetting thresholds.
  • Acclimation. Most manufacturers ask for the planks to sit in the room before installation. Following their instructions protects the warranty.

Our flooring installation team checks these during the in-home visit. We install both floors across the area, including flooring in Towson, Owings Mills and Pikesville, often as part of a larger kitchen or basement remodel.

Key takeaways

  • LVP is the safer pick wherever water is likely: kitchens, baths, laundry rooms and basements.
  • Laminate is thicker and firmer underfoot and works well in dry living areas and bedrooms.
  • HomeGuide lists installed prices of $4 to $14 per square foot for laminate and $4 to $16 for luxury vinyl.
  • Subfloor prep, stairs and removing old flooring can move the price as much as the product you choose.

Frequently asked questions

Is luxury vinyl plank better than laminate?
Neither is better everywhere. Luxury vinyl plank is the safer pick for kitchens, bathrooms, laundry rooms and basements because new vinyl products are waterproof. Laminate is thicker, feels firmer underfoot and works well in dry living rooms, bedrooms and upper floors.
Which costs more, laminate or vinyl plank?
They overlap. HomeGuide lists laminate at $4 to $14 per square foot installed and luxury vinyl plank or tile at $4 to $16 installed. Materials run $1 to $6 per square foot for laminate and $2 to $10 for vinyl. Subfloor prep, stairs and old flooring removal change the total.
Can laminate go in a kitchen or bathroom?
Standard laminate resists spills but is not waterproof, and water that gets into the seams can make it swell. Some newer laminates are sold as waterproof, so check the product rating. In full bathrooms and laundry rooms, vinyl plank or tile is the safer choice.
What is the better floor for a basement?
Luxury vinyl plank is usually the better fit for a basement because it is not damaged by moisture the way a wood-based laminate core can be. Test the slab for moisture first and fix any water problems, since no floor solves a wet basement.
How long do laminate and vinyl plank floors last?
Published estimates vary. HomeGuide lists 10 to 25 years for laminate and 20 to 50 years for luxury vinyl, while Angi puts laminate at 10 to 30 years and vinyl at 10 to 25 years. Product quality, the wear layer, installation and traffic make the biggest difference.

Not sure which floor fits your rooms?

Wall to Wall Construction installs laminate, luxury vinyl plank, hardwood and tile across Central Maryland. We will look at your subfloor, bring samples and give you a clear, itemized estimate. Prefer to write? Use our contact page.

Sources: HomeGuide, laminate vs. vinyl flooring costs; Angi, laminate vs. vinyl flooring. Costs are national figures and vary by project, location, materials and site conditions.
Wall to Wall Construction, LLC · 11 Newburg Ave, Ste 100, Catonsville, MD 21228 · 410-788-3990 · MHIC #123700
Call Request A Quote